

浏览全部资源
扫码关注微信
1.同济大学土木工程学院地下建筑与工程系,上海 200092
2.云南省交通规划设计研究院有限公司,云南 昆明 650041
Received:22 June 2023,
Revised:2023-10-16,
Published:25 June 2024
移动端阅览
周鸣亮,李泽豫,黄宏伟等.考虑施工时序的隧道工作面坍塌风险分析方法与验证[J].防灾减灾工程学报,2024,44(03):579-595.
ZHOU Mingliang,LI Zeyu,HUANG Hongwei,et al.Method and Validation for Tunnel Face Collapse Risk Analysis Considering Construction Sequence[J].Journal of Disaster Prevention and Mitigation Engineering,2024,44(03):579-595.
周鸣亮,李泽豫,黄宏伟等.考虑施工时序的隧道工作面坍塌风险分析方法与验证[J].防灾减灾工程学报,2024,44(03):579-595. DOI: 10.13409/j.cnki.jdpme.20230622001.
ZHOU Mingliang,LI Zeyu,HUANG Hongwei,et al.Method and Validation for Tunnel Face Collapse Risk Analysis Considering Construction Sequence[J].Journal of Disaster Prevention and Mitigation Engineering,2024,44(03):579-595. DOI: 10.13409/j.cnki.jdpme.20230622001.
岩石隧道钻爆法开挖过程中存在多工序交叉作业,且频繁遭遇复杂的地质环境,导致工作面坍塌事故时有发生。为分析隧道施工中工作面坍塌风险,结合T‑S(Takagi‑Sugeno)模糊事故树与贝叶斯网络,提出了一种考虑岩石隧道施工基本事件时序性的工作面坍塌风险分析方法。广泛调研了46起钻爆法岩石隧道工作面坍塌事故,筛选辨识出影响工作面稳定性的30项致险因子与孕险环境作为基本事件,基于统计数据量化计算各基本事件的发生概率模糊子集与各节点间条件概率,构建了隧道工作面坍塌T‑S模糊事故树并映射为贝叶斯网络,运用贝叶斯网络的双向推理功能,计算得到各基本事件的后验概率与重要度,筛选出部分对隧道工作面坍塌影响较大的关键基本事件。随后结合隧道施工过程中各基本事件发生的时序性,通过在贝叶斯网络中逐次更新对应事件的风险状态,得到工作面坍塌风险发生概率的时序性变化。以油坊坪隧道坍塌事故为工程实例,讨论了隧道建设中考虑施工时序的工作面坍塌风险分析的可行性与挑战,给出了岩石隧道不同施工阶段的风险管控方案与重点,为岩石隧道施工安全风险分析与管控提供了新的理论基础与技术手段。
Rock tunnel excavation using the drill-and-blast method often involves multiple concurrent operations and encounters complex geological conditions
leading to the occurrence of tunnel face collapse accidents. To analyze the risk of tunnel face collapse during tunnel construction
a risk analysis method considering the temporality sequence of basic events during rock tunnel construction was proposed
utilizing T-S (Takagi-Sugeno) fuzzy fault trees and Bayesian network. Extensive research was conducted on 46 tunnel face collapse accidents in rock tunnels excavated using the drill-and-blast method. Thirty hazardous factors and risk-prone environments were identified as basic events. The occurrence probabilities and conditional probabilities between nodes were quantitatively calculated based on statistical data
generating fuzzy subsets for the occurrence probabilities of each basic event. A T-S fuzzy fault tree for tunnel face collapse was constructed and mapped to a Bayesian network. By employing the bidirectional inference capability of Bayesian networks
the posterior probabilities and importance of each basic event were calculated
and the key basic events that had a significant impact on tunnel face collapse were identified and selected. Furthermore
considering the temporal occurrence of basic events during the tunnel construction process
the risk status of corresponding events was sequentially updated in the Bayesian network
enabling the assessment of the temporal variations in the probability of tunnel face collapse risk. Using the collapse accident in the Youfangping Tunnel as an engineering example
the feasibility and challenges of considering construction sequencing in the risk analysis of tunnel collapses during tunnel construction were discussed
Risk management strategies and focal points for different construction phases of rock tunnels were provided. This research offers a novel theoretical framework and technical means for the analysis and management of safety risks in rock tunnel construction.
李术才 , 周宗青 , 李利平 , 等 . 岩溶隧道突水风险评价理论与方法及工程应用 [J]. 岩石力学与工程学报 , 2013 , 32 ( 9 ): 1858 ‑ 1867 .
Li S C , Zhou Z Q , Li L P , et al . Risk evaluation theory and method of water inrush in karst tunnels and its applications [J]. Chinese Journal of Rock Mechanics and Engineering , 2013 , 32 ( 9 ): 1858 ‑ 1867 . (in Chinese)
陈洁金 , 周峰 , 阳军生 , 等 . 山岭隧道塌方风险模糊层次分析 [J]. 岩土力学 , 2009 , 30 ( 8 ): 2365 ‑ 2370 .
Chen J J , Zhou F , Yang J S , et al . Fuzzy analytic hierarchy process for risk evaluation of collapse during construction of mountain tunnel [J]. Rock and Soil Mechanics , 2009 , 30 ( 8 ): 2365 ‑ 2370 . (in Chinese)
张民庆 , 黄鸿健 , 张生学 , 等 . 宜万铁路马鹿箐隧道1·21突水突泥抢险治理技术 [J]. 铁道工程学报 , 2008 ( 11 ): 49 ‑ 56,61 .
Zhang M Q , Huang H J , Zhang S X , et al . Treatment technology for water and mud bursting on 1·21 in Maluqing tunnel of Yichang‑Wanzhou railway [J]. Journal of Railway Engineering Society , 2008 ( 11 ): 49 ‑ 56,61 . (in Chinese)
Wu L , Wan J W , Chen G , et al . Cause of the "8·5" water burst incident at Yesanguan tunnel along the Yi‑Wan railway [J]. Carsologica Sinica , 2009 , 28 ( 2 ): 212 ‑ 218 .
王伟 , 苗德海 . 宜万铁路齐岳山隧道F11高压富水断层特征及工程对策 [J]. 铁道标准设计 , 2010 ( 8 ): 81 ‑ 86 .
Wang W , Miao D H . Characteristics of high pressure watery fault F11 in Qiyueshan tunnel on Yichang-Wanzhou railway as well as engineering countermeasures [J]. Railway Standard Design , 2010 ( 8 ): 81 ‑ 86 . (in Chinese)
陈舞 , 张国华 , 王浩 , 等 . 基于T‑S模糊故障树的钻爆法施工隧道坍塌可能性评价 [J]. 岩土力学 , 2019 , 40 ( 增1 ): 319 ‑ 328 .
Chen W , Zhang G H , Wang H , et al . Evaluation of possibility of tunnel collapse by drilling and blasting method based on T‑S fuzzy fault tree [J]. Rock and Soil Mechanics , 2019 , 40 ( Sup1 ): 319 ‑ 328 . (in Chinese)
路美丽 , 刘维宁 , 罗富荣 , 等 . 隧道与地下工程风险评估方法研究进展 [J]. 工程地质学报 , 2006 , 14 ( 4 ): 462 ‑ 469 .
Lu M L , Liu W N , Luo F R , et al . Review on risk assessment methods for tunnelling and underground projects [J]. Journal of Engineering Geology , 2006 , 14 ( 4 ): 462 ‑ 469 . (in Chinese)
张晨曦 , 吴顺川 , 吴金 . 山岭隧道施工中塌方风险评估模型研究及应用 [J]. 中国安全生产科学技术 , 2019 , 15 ( 9 ): 128 ‑ 134 .
Zhang C X , Wu S C , Wu J . Study on risk assessment model of collapse during construction of mountain tunnel and its application [J]. Journal of Safety Science and Technology , 2019 , 15 ( 9 ): 128 ‑ 134 . (in Chinese)
许振浩 , 李术才 , 李利平 , 等 . 基于层次分析法的岩溶隧道突水突泥风险评估 [J]. 岩土力学 , 2011 , 32 ( 6 ): 1757 ‑ 1766 .
Xu Z H , Li S C , Li L P , et al . Risk assessment of water or mud inrush of karst tunnels based on analytic hierarchy process [J]. Rock and Soil Mechanics , 2011 , 32 ( 6 ): 1757 ‑ 1766 . (in Chinese)
曹文贵 , 翟友成 , 张永杰 . 新奥法隧道施工风险非线性模糊评判方法 [J]. 土木工程学报 , 2010 , 43 ( 7 ): 105 ‑ 112 .
Cao W G , Zhai Y C , Zhang Y J . Nonlinear fuzzy judgment method of construction risk for NATM tunneling [J]. China Civil Engineering Journal , 2010 , 43 ( 7 ): 105 ‑ 112 . (in Chinese)
陈舞 , 张国华 , 王浩 , 等 . 基于粗糙集条件信息熵的山岭隧道坍塌风险评价 [J]. 岩土力学 , 2019 , 40 ( 9 ): 3549 ‑ 3558 .
Chen W , Zhang G H , Wang H , et al . Risk assessment of mountain tunnel collapse based on rough set and conditional information entropy [J]. Rock and Soil Mechanics , 2019 , 40 ( 9 ): 3549 ‑ 3558 . (in Chinese)
孙景来 . 山岭隧道钻爆法施工坍塌风险及围岩稳定性评价研究 [D]. 北京 : 北京交通大学 , 2019 .
Sun J L . Study on collapse risk and stability evaluation in mining construction of mountain tunnel [D]. Beijing : Beijing Jiaotong University , 2019 . (in Chinese)
谢洪涛 , 丁祖德 . 基于贝叶斯网络的隧道施工坍塌事故诊断方法 [J]. 昆明理工大学学报(自然科学版) , 2013 , 38 ( 1 ): 37 ‑ 44 .
Xie H T , Ding Z D . Bayesian network based method for accident diagnosis of tunnel collapse [J]. Journal of Kunming University of Science and Technology(Science and Technology) , 2013 , 38 ( 1 ): 37 ‑ 44 . (in Chinese)
赵茗年 , 王永刚 , 庞小冲 , 等 . 高寒地区公路特长隧道风险评估优化应用 [J]. 地下空间与工程学报 , 2020 , 16 ( 增1 ): 426 ‑ 430 .
Zhao M N , Wang Y G , Pang X C , et al . Optimization application of risk assessment for super long highway tunnel in alpine region [J]. Chinese Journal of Underground Space and Engineering , 2020 , 16 ( Sup1 ): 426 ‑ 430 . (in Chinese)
闫玉茹 , 黄宏伟 , 胡群芳 , 等 . 大连湾海底隧道钻爆法施工风险评估研究 [J]. 岩石力学与工程学报 , 2007 , 26 ( 增2 ): 3616 ‑ 3624 .
Yan Y R , Huang H W , Hu Q F , et al . Risk assessment on drill and blasting method of Dalian bay subsea tunnel [J]. Chinese Journal of Rock Mechanics and Engineering , 2007 , 26 ( Sup2 ): 3616 ‑ 3624 . (in Chinese)
Fussell J B , Powers G J , Bennetts R G . Fault trees‑a state of the art discussion [J]. IEEE Transactions on Reliability , 1974 , 23 ( 1 ): 51 ‑ 55 .
卜全民 , 王涌涛 , 汪德爟 . 事故树分析法的应用研究 [J]. 西南石油大学学报 , 2007 , 29 ( 4 ): 141 ‑ 144,200 .
Bu Q M , Wang Y T , Wang D G . The application of fault tree analysis [J]. Journal of Southwest Petroleum University , 2007 , 29 ( 4 ): 141 ‑ 144,200 . (in Chinese)
Langseth H , Portinale L . Bayesian networks in reliability [J]. Reliability Engineering & System Safety , 2005 , 92 ( 1 ): 92 ‑ 108 .
李泽荃 , 孙景来 , 陈磊 . 基于事故树和贝叶斯网络的隧道塌陷风险概率估计方法研究 [J]. 煤炭工程 , 2020 , 52 ( 4 ): 130 ‑ 136 .
Li Z Q , Sun J L , Chen L . Risk assessment for tunnel collapse based on fault tree analysis and Bayesian Network [J]. Coal Engineering , 2020 , 52 ( 4 ): 130 ‑ 136 . (in Chinese)
章龙管 , 刘绥美 , 李开富 , 等 . 基于故障树与贝叶斯网络的地铁盾构施工风险预测 [J]. 现代隧道技术 , 2021 , 58 ( 5 ): 21 ‑ 29,55 .
Zhang L G , Liu S M , Li K F , et al . Prediction of shield construction risks in subway tunnelling based on fault tree and bayesian network [J]. Modern Tunnelling Technology , 2021 , 58 ( 5 ): 21 ‑ 29,55 . (in Chinese)
Zhou M , Chen J , Huang H , et al . Multi‑source data driven method for assessing the rock mass quality of a NATM tunnel face via hybrid ensemble learning models [J]. International Journal of Rock Mechanics and Mining Sciences , 2021 , 147 : 104914 .
Xue Y , Cao Y , Zhou M , et al . Rock mass fracture maps prediction based on spatiotemporal image sequence modeling [J]. Computer‐Aided Civil and Infrastructure Engineering , 2023 , 38 ( 4 ): 470 ‑ 488 .
陈龙 , 黄宏伟 . 岩石隧道工程风险浅析 [J]. 岩石力学与工程学报 , 2005 , 24 ( 1 ): 110 ‑ 115 .
Chen L , Huang H W . Risk analysis of rock tunnel engineering [J]. Chinese Journal of Rock Mechanics and Engineering , 2005 , 24 ( 1 ): 110 ‑ 115 . (in Chinese)
Takagi T , Sugeno M . Fuzzy identification of systems and its application to modeling and control [J]. Ieee Transactions on Systems Man and Cybernetics , 1985 , 15 ( 1 ): 116 ‑ 132 .
宋华 , 张洪钺 , 王行仁 . T‑S模糊故障树分析方法 [J]. 控制与决策 , 2005 , 20 ( 8 ): 854 ‑ 859 .
Song H , Zhang H Y , Wang X R . Fuzzy fault tree analysis based on T‑S model [J]. Control and Decision , 2005 , 20 ( 8 ): 854 ‑ 859 . (in Chinese)
姚成玉 , 张荧驿 , 王旭峰 , 等 . T‑S模糊故障树重要度分析方法 [J]. 中国机械工程 , 2011 , 22 ( 11 ): 1261 ‑ 1268 .
Yao C Y , Zhang Y Y , Wang X F , et al . Importance analysis method of fuzzy fault tree based on T‑S model [J]. China Mechanical Engineering , 2011 , 22 ( 11 ): 1261 ‑ 1268 . (in Chinese)
陈东宁 , 姚成玉 , 党振 . 基于T‑S模糊故障树和贝叶斯网络的多态液压系统可靠性分析 [J]. 中国机械工程 , 2013 , 24 ( 7 ): 899 ‑ 905 .
Chen D N , Yao C Y , Dang Z . Reliability analysis of multi‑state hydraulic system based on T‑S fuzzy fault tree and bayesian network [J]. China Mechanical Engineering , 2013 , 24 ( 7 ): 899 ‑ 905 . (in Chinese)
陈舞 , 王浩 , 张国华 , 等 . 基于T‑S模糊故障树和贝叶斯网络的隧道坍塌易发性评价 [J]. 上海交通大学学报 , 2020 , 54 ( 8 ): 820 ‑ 830 .
Chen W , Wang H , Zhang G H , et al . Evaluation of tunnel collapse susceptibility based on T‑S fuzzy fault tree and bayesian network [J]. Journal of Shanghai Jiaotong University , 2020 , 54 ( 8 ): 820 ‑ 830 . (in Chinese)
郑来 , 顾鹏 , 卢健 . 基于T‑S模糊故障树和贝叶斯网络的重特大交通事故成因分析 [J]. 交通信息与安全 , 2021 , 39 ( 4 ): 43 ‑ 51,59 .
Zheng L , Gu P , Lu J . A cause analysis of extraordinarily severe traffic crashes based on T‑S fuzzy fault tree and bayesian network [J]. Journal of Transport Information and Safety , 2021 , 39 ( 4 ): 43 ‑ 51,59 . (in Chinese)
周宗青 , 李术才 , 李利平 , 等 . 浅埋隧道塌方地质灾害成因及风险控制 [J]. 岩土力学 , 2013 , 34 ( 5 ): 1375 ‑ 1382 .
Zhou Z Q , Li S C , Li L P , et al . Causes of geological hazards and risk control of collapse in shallow tunnels [J]. Rock and Soil Mechanics , 2013 , 34 ( 5 ): 1375 ‑ 1382 . (in Chinese)
Man J , Zhou M , Zhang D , et al . Face stability analysis of circular tunnels in layered rock masses using the upper bound theorem [J]. Journal of Rock Mechanics and Geotechnical Engineering , 2022 , 14 ( 6 ): 1836 ‑ 1848 .
Li Z , Huang H , Zhou M , et al . Failure responses of rock tunnel faces during excavation through the fault‑fracture zone [J]. Underground Space , 2023 , 10 : 166 ‑ 181 .
Zhou M , Xing Z , Nie C , et al . Accurate prediction of tunnel face deformations in the rock tunnel construction process via high‑granularity monitoring data and attention‑based deep learning model [J]. Applied Sciences , 2022 , 12 ( 19 ): 9523 .
刘靖 , 艾智勇 , 苏辉 . 山岭隧道新奥法施工过程动态风险评估 [J]. 同济大学学报(自然科学版) , 2012 , 40 ( 8 ): 1142 ‑ 1146 .
Liu J , Ai Z Y , Su H . Dynamic risk assessment of mountain tunnel during NATM construction [J]. Journal of Tongji University(Natural Science) , 2012 , 40 ( 8 ): 1142 ‑ 1146 . (in Chinese)
许振浩 , 李术才 , 李利平 , 等 . 基于风险动态评估与控制的岩溶隧道施工许可机制 [J]. 岩土工程学报 , 2011 , 33 ( 11 ): 1714 ‑ 1725 .
Xu Z H , Li S C , Li L P , et al . Construction permit mechanism of karst tunnels based on dynamic assessment and management of risk [J]. Chinese Journal of Geotechnical Engineering , 2011 , 33 ( 11 ): 1714 ‑ 1725 . (in Chinese)
李宜城 , 薛亚东 , 李彦杰 . 一种基于动态权重的施工安全风险评估新方法 [J]. 地下空间与工程学报 , 2017 , 13 ( 增1 ): 209 ‑ 215 .
Li Y C , Xue Y D , Li Y J . A new construction risk aassessment method based on dynamic weight [J]. Chinese Journal of Underground Space and Engineering , 2017 , 13 ( Sup1 ): 209 ‑ 215 . (in Chinese)
卢鑫月 , 许成顺 , 侯本伟 , 等 . 基于动态贝叶斯网络的地铁隧道施工风险评估 [J]. 岩土工程学报 , 2022 , 44 ( 3 ): 492 ‑ 501 .
Lu X Y , Xu C S , Hou B W , et al . Risk assessment of metro construction based on dynamic Bayesian network [J]. Chinese Journal of Geotechnical Engineering , 2022 , 44 ( 3 ): 492 ‑ 501 . (in Chinese)
蒋涛 . 隧道塌方特征分析和预报预警监测系统的研究 [D]. 北京 : 北京交通大学 , 2016 .
Jiang T . Analysis of the characteristics of tunnel collapse and research on forecasting and early warning-monitoring system [D]. Beijing : Beijing Jiaotong University , 2016 . (in Chinese)
张军伟 , 陈云尧 , 陈拓 , 等 . 2006—2016年我国隧道施工事故发生规律与特征分析 [J]. 现代隧道技术 , 2018 , 55 ( 3 ): 10 ‑ 17 .
Zhang J W , Chen Y Y , Chen T , et al . Law and characteristics analysis of domestic tunnel construction accidents from 2006 to 2016 [J]. Modern Tunnelling Technology , 2018 , 55 ( 3 ): 10 ‑ 17 . (in Chinese)
HSE . Safety of new Austrian tunnelling method (NATM) tunnels [R]. London : [ s.n. ], 1996 .
CEDD . Catalogue of notable tunnel failure case histories [R]. HongKong : [ s.n. ], 2009 .
Chen J , Liu W , Chen L , et al . Failure mechanisms and modes of tunnels in monoclinic and soft‑hard interbedded rocks: a case study [J]. KSCE Journal of Civil Engineering , 2020 , 24 ( 4 ): 1357 ‑ 1373 .
陈其学 , 江勇顺 , 唐浩 . 飞仙关特长隧道高压涌突水形成机制及处治技术研究 [J]. 现代隧道技术 , 2016 , 53 ( 4 ): 143 ‑ 147 .
Chen Q X , Jiang Y S , Tang H . Formation and treatment of the high‑pressure water inflow in the extra‑long Feixianguan tunnel [J]. Modern Tunnelling Technology , 2016 , 53 ( 4 ): 143 ‑ 147 . (in Chinese)
Tanii K , Hirota M , Kikuchi Y , et al . Design and construction of countermeasure for record‑breaking land collapse [J]. Proceedings of Tunnel Engineering Jsce , 2002 , 12 : 297 ‑ 302 .
李学东 , 董健 , 任亚 , 等 . 龙潭特长公路隧道突水涌泥坍塌治理措施探讨 [J]. 中外公路 , 2008 , 28 ( 6 ): 179 ‑ 183 .
Li X D , Dong J , Ren Y , et al . Discussion on treatment measures of water and mad inrush collapse of Longtan Long Highway tunnel [J]. Journal of China & Foreign Highway , 2008 , 28 ( 6 ): 179 ‑ 183 . (in Chinese)
Pearl J. Fusion , propagation , and structuring in belief networks [J]. Artificial Intelligence , 1986 , 29 ( 3 ): 241 ‑ 288 .
左清军 , 吴立 , 林存友 , 等 . 富水软岩隧道跨越断层段塌方机制分析及处治措施 [J]. 岩石力学与工程学报 , 2016 , 35 ( 2 ): 369 ‑ 377 .
Zuo Q J , Wu L , Lin C Y , et al . Collapse mechanism and treatment measures for tunnel in water‑rich soft rock crossing fault [J]. Chinese Journal of Rock Mechanics and Engineering , 2016 , 35 ( 2 ): 369 ‑ 377 . (in Chinese)
Zhou M , Shadabfar M , Xue Y , et al . Probabilistic analysis of tunnel roof deflection under sequential excavation using ANN‑based Monte Carlo simulation and simplified reliability approach [J]. ASCE‑ASME Journal of Risk and Uncertainty in Engineering Systems , Part A: Civil Engineering, 2021 , 7 ( 4 ): 04021043 .
0
Views
0
下载量
0
CSCD
Publicity Resources
Related Articles
Related Author
Related Institution
苏公网安备32010202012147号